My Icart etching doesn’t look good. What can I do about it?

Most Icart etchings that are in original frames with original mats have problems, such as foxing, light darkening, glue or acidity, amongst others. Read yesterday’s blog for a more complete explanation.

Icart "Lady of the Camelias", with original frame and mat

Icart "Lady of the Camelias", with original frame and mat

Some people like them that way. They show their age (usually 70-90 years old). They’re probably authentic (it’s difficult to fake the brittleness and other signs of age). They have character, with nicks in the frame and faded mats. The problem is they’re getting worse, year after year. The degradation continues with constant exposure to high acid levels, bright light and humidity. Remember the value is in the etching itself, a sheet of paper. It’s the cake, while the mat and frame are the frosting. Good restorers are capable of reversing most of the damage that’s accrued in almost a century.

The process starts by removing the etching from the frame. That’s pretty simple. There is usually a paper backing that can be torn off. (It can’t be reused so it doesn’t matter if you tear it off.) Below that is the backboard. That’s usually held in with many nails around the perimeter on older frames. Later frames may have framing points. Either one can be removed with a flat screwdriver and a needle nose pliers.

Framing points

Framing points

Then the backboard is removed to get to the etching underneath. Depending on the technique of the original framer (and they had many different styles), the etching may be a loose sheet that’s taped on the top or the edges (that would be the best). Usually the etching is found within a glue sandwich — glued to the board in the back and the mat in the front. Every variation is possible — the etching may be glued only to the mat in front, or only to the board in the back or only glued around the edges or best of all, no glue at all.

The restorer then puts the etching in a full bath and begins the process of separating the paper from anything it’s glued to and then to removing the glue itself. Sometimes the glue softens and the job of removal is facilitated, but on occasion the glue is tenacious and removal becomes a very labor intensive and time-consuming process. It’s very easy to damage a soaking wet etching, so this job should be left to a professional.

Once the sheet has been freed, a chemical process is started that in most cases can reverse most of the effects of aging. (Sounds wonderful to me. I’d like to get dipped myself and see if I can reverse the effects of aging.) If it’s done properly, the foxing can be eliminated and the light darkening and acid burns can be reversed.  The etching is then thoroughly washed, which eliminates most of the acid. A buffering solution can be added to slow down future acid buildup and finally the etching is dried in a press. Most of the hand-painted details like lipstick are lost in the restoration process and have to be reapplied by hand.

Now the etching is a loose sheet that looks almost as good as the day it was made. It’s ready to be framed properly by modern standards. That means that non-acidic materials are used in the framing and mounting. Rag mats are made of cotton and are pH neutral (A pH of 7 is neutral). Anything that comes in contact with the etching either is acid-free or separated by an acid-free barrier. With proper conservation and framing, your etching will look great and last for many more years.

Contact me if you have an etching that needs conservation.

Please send me your suggestions or questions about art glass, lamps, Louis Icart, shows, auctions, etc. If it’s interesting, I’ll answer your question in a future blog entry.

Call or write and let me know what you would like to buy, sell, or trade. philchasen@gmail or 516-922-2090. And please visit my website.

8 thoughts on “My Icart etching doesn’t look good. What can I do about it?

  1. I have a Louis Icart “Don Juan”. It is in excellent condition. I don’t know if I want to sell it or not, but would like to know some one in the Portland, OR area who could authenticate it for me. Thanks for your time.

  2. I have two original Icart etchings (numbered and windmill ect..)…Joy of Life and Werther. I believe they are in their original frames and mating. They were passed down to me from my parents. They are in good condition, but I would like to modernize them and conserve them because they are dirty. Can you give me any advice where to go to get this done properly and approx. how much it would cost? Would it add to their value? I’m not planning on selling them just want them a little more modern. Thank you.

  3. hi, is it important if the signature is erased when the etching is in bath for restoration? thank you

  4. Why would the signature get erased in the bath? That doesn’t happen to authentic signatures.

  5. Hello.
    Thank you for the opportunity to speak to an expert such as yourself.
    I see that you have for sale Icarts’s in new museum quality frames and some say original frames. When do you think it best to leave in the original frame? I have “Speed” in what appears to be original frame (that is not really attractive and appears to be repainted with “radiator” paint) but I am concerned about the probably 90 year old cardboard I see as backing. So far it does not seem to have impacted the print, but my gut says take it out.
    Thank you very much.

  6. I don’t deal much in Icart etchings anymore, mostly glass and lamps, but I am an expert. When I would get an etching in the original frame, I would almost always remove the etching from the frame and “conserve” it. That meant putting it through a process that removed it from its backing and cleaned up the foxing, etc. If the frame were in good condition, I would reuse it, but most of the time I threw them out.

    I can take care of restoring your etching. My fee is $200 + return shipping. Please let me know if you wish to proceed.

  7. I emailed you directly this morning, but thought I would also comment here. I am considering purchasing an Icart etching that is glued down to cardboard. Is this typical? Would you be able to remove the cardboard and restore the etching? Approximately how much would this cost? Do you also reframe etchings?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.